Paying extra on a mortgage earns a guaranteed return equal to your mortgage rate, because it removes interest you would otherwise owe. Investing offers a higher expected return but no guarantee. The higher your mortgage rate, the stronger the case for paying it down. The lower your rate, the stronger the case for investing. Your emergency fund, employer match, other debts and how you feel about risk should come first.
The core idea
Every extra dollar you put on your mortgage stops interest from being charged on that dollar for the rest of the loan. That is a return of exactly your mortgage rate, before tax effects, and it is certain. At 6.5%, for example, an extra $500 a month on a $400,000 loan saves $205,559 in interest and finishes 10 years 7 months early.
Investing the same money could earn more, or less, or lose value for a while. Historically, broad stock market investments have beaten mortgage rates over many long periods and fallen short over others, and nobody can say which this will be. So the real question is whether the extra return you might earn is worth the risk of not getting it.
Why your mortgage rate matters most
The same $500 extra payment on the same $400,000, 30-year loan is worth very different amounts at different rates:
| Mortgage rate | Paid off in | Time saved | Interest saved |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3% | 20 yrs 5 mos | 9 yrs 7 mos | $71,795 |
| 4.5% | 20 yrs 1 mo | 9 yrs 11 mos | $121,707 |
| 6.5% | 19 yrs 5 mos | 10 yrs 7 mos | $205,559 |
| 8% | 18 yrs 10 mos | 11 yrs 2 mos | $282,453 |
A rate of 3% makes extra payments a modest win. A rate of 8% makes them a big one. When your mortgage is cheap, a guaranteed 3% looks small next to what investing might earn. When it is expensive, a guaranteed 8% is hard to beat.
An illustration
To compare directly, take one monthly budget of $3,028.27 and spend it two ways for 30 years:
- Option A, prepay first: put all $3,028.27 on the mortgage until it is paid off in 19 years 5 months, then invest the full amount for the remaining 10 years 7 months.
- Option B, invest alongside: pay the regular $2,528.27 and invest the other $500 every month for 30 years.
Both end with a paid-off house. The difference is the size of the investment account at year 30, assuming a steady yearly return, with no taxes or fees:
| Assumed yearly return | A: prepay, then invest | B: invest alongside | Who comes out ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3% | $451,994 | $291,368 | Prepaying, by $160,625 |
| 5% | $505,589 | $416,129 | Prepaying, by $89,460 |
| 6.5% | $551,169 | $553,089 | About even |
| 8% | $602,013 | $745,180 | Investing, by $143,166 |
| 10% | $679,164 | $1,130,244 | Investing, by $451,080 |
The break-even sits almost exactly at the mortgage rate. If your investments earn less than 6.5% a year, prepaying comes out ahead. If they earn more, investing does. The catch is that the prepaying result is guaranteed, while a steady 8% or 10% for 30 years is a hypothetical. Real returns vary year to year, and a bad early decade can hurt a lot. This is an illustration of the trade-off, not a forecast.
Questions to ask before you choose
- Do you have an emergency fund? Many planners suggest several months of expenses in cash. Money in a mortgage is hard to get back out.
- Does your employer match retirement contributions? A match is usually an immediate return that beats any mortgage rate.
- Do you have higher-rate debt? Credit card or personal loan balances usually cost more than a mortgage and come first.
- Do you pay mortgage insurance? Extra payments can get you to the point where it can be cancelled. The CFPB explains the rules for removing PMI.
- Do you itemize your taxes? Mortgage interest only reduces your tax bill if you itemize, and many households take the standard deduction instead. If you do not itemize, paying less interest has no tax cost. IRS Publication 936 covers the rules.
- How will you feel? Some people sleep better with no mortgage. Others prefer the flexibility of cash and investments. Both are reasonable.
A middle path
You do not have to choose one. Common compromises are:
- Build your emergency fund and capture any employer match first, then send extra money to the mortgage.
- Split extra cash between investing and prepaying, and adjust the split as your rate, income and comfort change.
- Prepay while your rate is high, and shift toward investing if you refinance to a lower one.
To see what a specific extra payment does on your loan, use the mortgage payoff calculator. For the mechanics of each strategy, read how to pay off your mortgage early. This guide is general education, not personal financial advice. A licensed financial planner can look at your whole situation.
Educational content, not financial advice. Numbers in this guide were calculated with our payoff calculator using the assumptions on the methodology page.